Holiday Perfectionism: Letting Go of the Perfect Holiday

My sister and I traded the big holiday meal for restaurant reservations, and I don't miss the dishes one bit. I'm Enid DeJesus, a licensed mental health counselor at Therapy with Enid, and this time of year, a lot of women are already tired of a holiday that hasn't happened yet. That pressure has a name: holiday perfectionism. If you're not sure where you land, my post on the signs of perfectionism is a good place to start.

Hands set a simple holiday table with plates, glasses, white candles, and fresh greenery.

What Holiday Perfectionism Looks Like

Holiday perfectionism isn't a clinical term. It's the familiar habit of turning a celebration into a performance review. It can look like:

  • The perfect plan. The menu, the gifts, the decorations, and the schedule all have to be just right, and you are the one holding every piece.

  • The perfect mood. Everyone has to get along and have a wonderful time, and if they don't, it feels like your fault.

  • The perfect picture. The photos have to look like the ones you scroll past online, even if the day behind them felt stressful.

You're far from alone in feeling the pressure. In a 2023 poll of more than 2,000 U.S. adults, 89 percent said something about the holiday season causes them stress, and 41 percent said their stress goes up during the holidays (American Psychological Association, 2023). Money, finding the right gifts, and missing loved ones topped the list.

You can love the holidays and still not want to run them like a project.

Why the Pressure Feels So Heavy

There isn't much research on holiday perfectionism specifically, so I want to be clear about that. What we do have is good research on perfectionism in general, and it helps explain the season.

Researchers separate perfectionism into two parts. Perfectionistic strivings are the drive to do something well. Perfectionistic concerns are the fear of mistakes and the harsh judgment that follows. A 2023 meta-analysis of studies with young people found the concerns were clearly linked to anxiety, while the strivings barely were (Lunn et al., 2023). In holiday terms, wanting a lovely dinner is fine. Believing the whole family will judge you if the rolls burn is what wears you down.

The sense that other people expect perfection from you has also been rising. A meta-analysis of more than 41,000 college students found this kind of "socially prescribed" perfectionism grew between 1989 and 2016 (Curran and Hill, 2019). That study wasn't about holidays, and it does fit a season full of family expectations and highlight reels.

A group of friends laughs and raises their hands at a festive holiday dinner table in front of a lit Christmas tree.

How to Let Go of the Perfect Holiday

Keep what you love and drop the rest

Make a short list of the traditions that bring you joy. Then list the ones you keep out of obligation. You don't have to cut everything on the second list, and you are allowed to cut some of it.

Lower the production

Restaurant reservations, store-bought dessert, or a smaller guest list all count as a real holiday. I bring a puzzle to family gatherings, and I drive myself so I can head home to my own bed when I'm done (my car is my exit plan). Small choices like that make a long day easier to enjoy.

Set one boundary ahead of time

Decide before the day what you will and won't do, whether that's how long you stay, which topics you'll skip, or who handles the dishes. My post on setting healthy boundaries with parents has language you can borrow.

Talk to yourself the way you'd talk to a friend

When something goes sideways, notice the inner critic and answer it kindly. Research links self-compassion to a weaker connection between perfectionism and depression (Ferrari et al., 2018). That study measured people at one point in time, so it isn't proof, and the idea is worth trying anyway.

For more ideas, read my guide for highly sensitive women during holiday celebrations if you're a highly sensitive person (HSP), my post on slow living during the holidays, and my post on how perfectionism and anxiety feed each other.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do I get so stressed during the holidays?

Many people do. Money, gifts, family dynamics, and missing loved ones are common stressors, and high expectations can turn each one into a test you feel you have to pass.

Is holiday perfectionism a sign of anxiety?

Not always. Many people feel extra pressure in December. If the worry is constant, hard to control, and lasts well beyond the season, it may be worth talking to a therapist about anxiety.

How do I stop trying to make the holidays perfect?

Start small. Keep the traditions you love, simplify one thing this year, and decide ahead of time how you'll answer the inner critic when something doesn't go to plan.

Therapy for Perfectionism in Florida

You are allowed to have a holiday that looks like yours and nobody else's. I'm a licensed therapist, and I offer online therapy in Florida for high-achieving women who are ready to put down the pressure to make everything perfect. Reach out to me and tell me a little about what this season brings up for you, and we can see if working together is a good fit.

Enid DeJesus is a licensed mental health counselor who provides online therapy in Florida for high-achieving, highly sensitive women. She helps women with perfectionism, anxiety, and people-pleasing enjoy the parts of life they love without the pressure to get every detail right.

Next
Next

Imposter Syndrome at Work: Reviews, Promotions and New Roles